By Bolarinwa Olajide
AFC Toronto spent the inaugural Northern Super League season proving they were the best team in the country. They finished first in the standings, lifted the Supporters’ Shield, and looked destined to become champions.
But when the final arrived, the dream slipped away.
Vancouver Rise stood in their path, and Toronto’s remarkable season ended not with a trophy celebration, but with heartbreak.
For months, that disappointment lingered.
The road back wasn’t easy. Toronto finished third in the regular-season standings while the Montreal Roses surged to the top, capturing the Supporters’ Shield and carrying a 12-match unbeaten streak into the playoffs. Confident, dominant, and seemingly unstoppable, the Roses entered the postseason as favourites.
But AFC Toronto had learned something valuable from heartbreak. They stormed through the semifinals, dismantling Ottawa 8-2 on aggregate and earning another shot on the league’s biggest stage. Waiting for them in Ottawa was the hottest team in the NSL: the Montreal Roses.
The final day arrived beneath grey November skies at TD Place in the Nation’s capital, Ottawa. Montreal pushed forward with the confidence of a team that had spent months at the top of the table. But Toronto refused to bend.
In the 39th minute, Lauren Rowe burst down the flank and found a pocket of space. Her pass rolled perfectly into the path of 17-year-old Olivia Chisholm. A player who had waited all season for her first professional goal.
Chisholm struck the ball cleanly, sending it beyond Gabrielle Lambert and into the back of the net.
In the biggest game of her young career, Chisholm delivered the defining moment of the season. Not in a regular-season match. Not in a playoff warm-up. It was the championship final.
Montreal attacked wave after wave, desperate for an equalizer. The league’s most dangerous attack threw everything forward, but Toronto stood firm. Sabrina D’Angelo came up with crucial saves. The players fought for every loose ball as if the entire season depended on it.
And when the final whistle finally sounded, the release was overwhelming. AFC Toronto were champions.
The team that once experienced the heartbreak of a championship defeat had returned stronger, wiser and more determined. One year after watching another club lift the trophy, AFC Toronto stood at the summit themselves.
Olivia Chisholm: “I’ve been waiting all season to score my first goal, so pretty good time to score and to celebrate with all my teammates and coaching staff.”
Head Coach Marko Milanovic: “The biggest thing is seeing everyone so happy. Players, their families, friends, everyone that made the trip from Toronto to support us. To me, that’s the best thing out of all of this.”
Captain Nikki Small: “We love to make history on this team. Last year celebrating the Shield, this is even better because it’s the Finals, and next year I think we’re looking to do both.”
Assistant Coach Sylvia Forbes: “It’s a privilege to stand by these girls every single day. They’ve shown day in and day out what it means to be a champion, and they’re just the most deserving players.”
Their journey from Supporters’ Shield winners, to heartbroken runners-up, to champions is already one of the defining stories of the young Northern Super League.
With a championship-winning core, emerging young stars and a culture built on resilience, AFC Toronto now has the opportunity to build something special.
The Diana B. Matheson Cup proved they could finish the job.
Now, with a championship in their hands and a city behind them, AFC Toronto can look to the future knowing that their greatest achievement may still be ahead.



Leave feedback about this